Allan Isfan is a co-founder of FaveQuest, a young start-up. This blog covers start-up topics.

Sunday, December 10, 2006

Google

strategy and the circus

First of all, apologies for slipping on the blog last week. I had some critical meetings which took my entire focus. The meetings went really well but it also highlighted that there is much work to do before takeoff. It was a good reminder to slow down a bit and focus on the basics 'figure out who you customer is, what is his problem and how you are going to solve it better tha anyone else'. Oh ... And you need to figure out how you're going to make money'. Oh and you need to figure out how your competition will react and how you're going to create a defensible position. The results need to be based on some sound research although some gut feel is required as well, especially when you're creating something revolutionary. Like I said earlier, lots to do. Fortunately I now have lots of capable people that can help me. Time to delegate.

A meeting with a very experienced and capable individual a couple of weeks ago reminded me of some basic, but often forgotten critical methods for pulling together real, defensible and sustainable strategies. I would like to share some of these, together with some associated examples. There are lots of concepts that pass for strategy that really are not and his recommendations were an excellent reminder to review my own strategy to ensure it actually is a strategy and that the position I'm creating is indeed defensible.

The basic premise of building a differentiated and defensible strategy is to choose a different set of goals and associated activities. Cirque du Soleil is good example I pulled from one the papers I just read. They chose to dispense with costly items such as animals and other things that did not fit in with their value proposition such as food concessions. Instead, they added high quality dance, music, venues and seating. Each of their shows has a theme and is quite different from others which allows you to see several totally different Cirque du Soleil shows if you wish. In constrast, the traditionals circus is pretty well the same every year .... you probably aren't compelled to go more that once a year (if ever:). Cirque du Soleil also targets a different customer. They are shooting primarily for adults even though some kids certainly go. It would be very unlikely that I would go to a traditional circus without my kids but I would and have gone to Cirque du Soleil without them. My wife and I recently paid $125/ticket for front row seats at the recent Delirium show, and I can tell you that I had no regrets ... a fantastic show! No way anyone would pay that for a traditional three ring circus.

Cirque du Soleil has built an extremely defensible position. Ideally, the competition doesn't even care untill it is too late. If the three ring circus tried to copy Cirque du Soleil, the result would likely be laughable. A critical part of a defensible strategy is tying together a number of key components, doing those really well and linking these to each other in a powerful way. This makes you very difficulut to imitate. Going back to Cirque du Soleil, they provide totally different experience by using out of this world high quality music tied to visual ambience, wild costumes, extreme acrobatics, fantastic dance and held in a decent venue. Very difficult to copy the formula and get it right. Even if you got close, their brand is strong enough that if you are looking for that kind of show, you go to Cirque du Soleil rather than an imitator. They have created a very defensible position.

So lets say we manage to create a defensible position by doing a number of activities differently and pulling these together tightly so that they build on each other making the whole thing difficult to imitate. How do we now sustain this strategic position? Assuming we are successful do create something different, compelling and defensible, presumably many will try to attack us. This is one of the most difficult things to figure out quite honestly. Some of the things that come to mind are obvious ... patent as much as you can, keep moving forward like crazy making each critical item better and better (remember "continuous improvement"?) and maybe add some new features and twist to the mix and perhaps create some strong relationships with key partners. Although you likely do continue to improve and add new capabilities, it probably isn't enough.

For a strategy to be defensible, it needs to be based on trade-offs. We need to chose what not to do and so do our competitors. If there are no trade-offs, there is not need for strategy ... just do everything. I've done this throughout my career and understand very well the trade-offs that need to be made in new products ... there are lots of things that just can't make it in and it is frustrating. However, the interesting stuff starts when you look at your competition and try to understand their business and motivations for doing certain things. If you understand the trade-offs they are going to make, then you can build a strong business because you'll have a good idea how they will react. Ideally what makes you special is exactly what your competitors will chose not to do.

Watcha talking about Willy?

Let me give you an example that will hit home if you are from a great little start-up in Ottawa called Catena. Catena created a plug in card for the SLC Series 5, an old product deployed by Lucent over the years with an installed base of nearly 20 Million lines. This product, named CNX-5, has been and continues to sell extremely well even though we were just a little start-up. How did we beat Alcatel, Lucent and all the other big players? The truth is that we didn't beat them ... we were just an annoying pimple and their big behind. Alcatel has better things to do than to build a custom solution for a small handful of customers ... their revenues from DSLAMs all over the world dwarfed our revenues and they must defend that fiercely against the other big guys. I'm pretty sure they weren't worried about us ... annoyed maybe. They would have had to drop their price dramatically to match our overall deployment costs in order to crush us and that would have cost them more than it was worth. For a small company, the revenues were amazing and we had a defensible position. We created some advanced technology that was very hard to duplicate, even by the top companies, and applied it to a significant market for our size. The technology and tenacity required was a barrier for other small companies and the market we attacked was large for us but not for our large competitors. A really good lesson to have lived through !!!

Ok ... enough with this dry stuff. Let's have a bit of fun. Check out this ad that was created through personiva (see link below). You can create your own through their website www.personiva.com . You upload your picture and it identifies your face then replaces the face of an actor in a comercial or anything else like such as a video game with your face. This company is shooting for a very different adverising model by being really neat, wacky and viral (i.e. the fact that I'm sending you this link is proof). The tech isn't so good that it fools you into thinking it was actually me in the commercial but that is what makes it extra funny in my opinion. Be sure to check out some of the different endings ... the disco one is really funny.

http://www.us.levi.com/lsco/levi/features/yourad/l_yourad.jsp?DetId=18499-7F6V6P0W6D2B7Y8

Cheers,

Allan

Labels: , , ,

Monday, November 13, 2006

Google

pretty cool stuff

During my last post, I promised I would identify some companies with cool technology I discovered at the Dow Jownes Technology Ventures conference I attended in San Jose last week. I suspect many of you may be interested in checking out some of these services. I share these without my VC hat on, just pure consumer perspective. Some of these companies may be trying to raise money but not all of them are.

Before, I get to that, I would like to signal a change to this blog. I have used this blog to share some thoughts on start-ups and to give people a sense for how I plan on building my new company and make it successful. Not everyone is interested in start-up topics and I have found many great resources/blogs written by others that do a great job of that (I've included link at the right of the page). As I find new ones, I'll share them with you but won't elaborate too much. A new blog I started reading is:



Note that I've also added a feature to my blog that allows you to type in your email and you will receive new and exciting posts from me in your inbox saving you the trouble of going to the web page or setting up an RSS reader. Look just below my profile. You barely have to lift a finger. Am I nice or what!!

I'm going to be migrating the topic to more cool topics in the space of music and video services, cool multi-media gadgets and evolution of multi-media. We all listen to radio, music, news, watch tv and go to movies and view movies at home. This space is experiencing dramatic changes. On the surface, things may still appear the same with people mostly watching broadcast t.v., listening to broadcast radio or reading newspapers. However, people are increasingly moving away from broadcast and spending time and effort to pick and choose what they want, when and where they want it. Add to that people's interest in more reality based content and people's desire to be heard and you get a major shift in how people will be entertained. The one thing that became clear from the conference is that there is a MAJOR shift in advertising dollars from broadcast to online services going on right about now. So ... hang on ... cause things are about to get interesting!

Cool stuff and companies:

www.earcandy.fm
-this is the URL for my new company. There is no website yet (just bought the URL last night). I'll let you know when the site is up and running
-will definitely be looking for $$

www.personiva.com

-have developed technology that puts you in real commercials
-the demo consisted of the presenter taking a picture of someone in the crowd and uploading it to their server. He then played a pepsi commercial (the one with the guy from SNL dancing on the car) and his face was automatically replaced with the picture of the guy in the crowd, complete with moving eyebrows and lips!
-the idea is that commercials become much more interesting when you're in them. It was really funny and they figure you'll forward the commercial to all your friends
-profitable and looking for investment in first half 2007

www.motionbox.com

-allows you to upload your personal videos, easily edit them and tag different sections so you can find the sections of interest later and search your library of videos
-also allows you to pick certain selections of the video and share those with others. For example, I filmed the hockey game and I share with you the times when your kid was on the ice
-these guys have done a very good job of making the interface ultra simple to use

www.mystrands.com

-have developed algorithms that allow certain types of services, such as music, to figure out what you might like next
-this doesn't seem very exciting on the surface but the applications that come out of this can be very powerful. There is just so much information out there that figuring out what you might be interested based on your history and preferences, together with others like you could be huge. Basically like search (google) but more proactive.
-one product that has popped out of this base is called partystrands. This is a system aimed at bars and clubs that allow people to text the music they want to hear ... essentially a social jukebox. Their requests and other messages and pictures go up on the various big screen tvs throughout the club together with advertising.
-launching in US and Spain (CEO is from Barcelona)
-unsure if they are raising money

www.fliptrack.com

-not launched yet (can put in your email and they'll contact you when the service is available)
-allows you to pick a song and synchronize pictures and videos to it
-they have over one hundred songs you can use, including lyrics.
-the founder showed pictures of his kids acting out the ABCs to the song ... very cute
-adding the music to a slide show makes it much more compelling, especially if you can synchronize it
-looks very easy to use
-currently trying to raise $1M

www.ejamming.com

-service that allows people to play music together, over the internet
-target is amateur and professional musicians, music education ...
-key trick is a timestamp based system to synchronize everyone since delays through the internet can be variable and mess things up
-you can use MIDI based instruments (like keyboards) or convert analog to MIDI using a small box so that you can plug in microphones, guitars ...
-with the scheduling challenges I see with "Funding Bad Habits", the dudes that play in my basement, together with the challenges I have scheduling keyboard and singing lessons, I could certainly see myself using this
-I spoke with the founders and execs of the company and you could not find a more passionate group!
-they are currently trying to raise an A round in the next few months.

I'm going to leave it at that for now. There are a few more cool companies I'd like to share but you've probably had more than enough by now.

Cheers,

Allan Isfan
Entrepreneur with an Iron Ring

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,